Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: Did Pope Leo XIII, Pope Leo I, or Pope Leo X make statements about Donald Trump?
Executive Summary
No credible evidence shows that historical pontiffs Pope Leo I (5th century), Pope Leo X (16th century) or Pope Leo XIII (19th century) ever made statements about Donald Trump. The contemporary reporting instead attributes commentary about Mr. Trump and his administration to a modern pontiff referenced in these sources as Pope Leo XIV, who publicly criticized U.S. immigration policy and discussed Trump-era issues in interviews and meetings with U.S. bishops in 2025. Contemporary coverage dates for those statements cluster in September–October 2025, and the available analyses consistently separate remarks by the modern pope from any historical Leos; therefore, claims linking Trump commentary to the earlier pontiffs are unfounded in the cited material [1] [2].
1. Clear separation between historical Leos and the modern pope — what the records show
The assembled analyses uniformly show no record of Pope Leo I, Leo X, or Leo XIII commenting on Donald Trump; those figures predate Trump by centuries and cannot have made contemporary political statements. Every source excerpt reviewed instead refers to commentary from Pope Leo XIV, described as a contemporary pope engaging with modern policy issues such as immigration and climate. The absence of any primary or secondary evidence linking the earlier Leos to statements about Trump is explicit across multiple writeups dated between May and October 2025, which repeatedly note the distinction between the historical pontiffs and comments attributed to the current pope [1] [3] [4].
2. What the modern pope said and where those statements appear in the record
Reporting from September–October 2025 documents that Pope Leo XIV criticized U.S. immigration policies and spoke to U.S. bishops about the human impact of deportation plans, and that he addressed the Trump administration’s approach in interviews and public remarks. Several articles summarize a first interview and episcopal meetings in which this pope said he would not involve himself in partisan politics but would raise his voice on matters affecting migrants, abuse, and LGBTQ+ Catholics, and specifically referenced Trump-era deportation proposals. These accounts are dated September 18 and October 8–24, 2025, demonstrating that the statements are recent and tied to the contemporary pontiff [5] [6] [2].
3. How different sources frame the pope’s comments — tone and emphasis
The sources present consistent factual claims with varying emphases: some focus on the pope’s direct critique of immigration policy, others on his broader pastoral priorities and insistence on nonpartisanship while criticizing specific policies. Coverage dated October 7–24, 2025 highlights the pope’s strongest challenges to Trump-era policy and his appeals to bishops, while a September 18, 2025 interview piece underscores his reluctance to engage in partisan politics alongside his willingness to speak on moral and humanitarian issues. The variation reflects editorial choice and audience focus rather than contradiction about whether the modern pope spoke on Trump-related matters [4] [7] [6].
4. Claims about historical popes and how misinformation can arise
Attributing modern political statements to historical figures such as Pope Leo I, Leo X, or Leo XIII likely arises from name confusion or misreading secondary summaries that conflate different popes. The reviewed analyses explicitly correct such conflations by noting that the texts do not mention those earlier Leos in relation to Donald Trump and instead consistently attribute contemporary commentary to Pope Leo XIV. This pattern indicates an information error rather than substantiated historical evidence; the primary documents cited in 2025 pieces make the distinction clear and offer no archival citations connecting the older popes to Trump-era politics [1] [3] [8].
5. Bottom line: verified facts and how to read future claims
The verified fact pattern is straightforward: no credible sources in the reviewed material attribute statements about Donald Trump to Pope Leo I, Leo X, or Leo XIII; contemporary statements about Trump are attributed to Pope Leo XIV in September–October 2025 coverage. Readers should treat any contrary claim with skepticism and check for precise identification of which “Pope Leo” is meant and for direct quotations dated to modern times. The sources used here consistently separate historical record from contemporary commentary, offering a clear corrective to any mistaken attributions [1] [2].