A single eruption from a volcano puts 10, 000 times more carbon dioxide into the atmosphere than all human activity has throughout history.
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
The claim that a single volcanic eruption injects 10,000 times more carbon dioxide into the atmosphere than all human activity in history is false: measured volcanic CO2 emissions are tiny compared with anthropogenic emissions, and even large explosive eruptions emit at most millions of tons of CO2 while humanity emits tens of billions of tons each year [1][2]. Social-media memes that assert otherwise conflate rare, extreme geologic events or short-term emission rates with cumulative human emissions and ignore the sustained, annual nature of fossil‑fuel burning [3][4].
1. Why the numbers don’t add up: volcanoes versus annual human emissions
Contemporary estimates place global volcanic CO2 emissions (land and submarine) at roughly 0.13–0.44 gigatons (130–440 million tonnes) per year or near ~200–360 million tonnes in many summaries, while human activities in recent years have emitted roughly 24–37 gigatons (24,000–37,000 million tonnes) of CO2 per year — making human annual emissions tens to hundreds of times larger than all volcanoes combined [5][6][7].
2. Single eruptions are dramatic but fleeting; rates don’t equal totals
Individual eruptions can briefly emit CO2 at rates comparable to human hourly rates — for example Mount St. Helens released about 10 million tonnes of CO2 in nine hours — yet even that dramatic pulse would be matched by humanity in only a few hours and is tiny compared with annual anthropogenic emissions; the largest historical eruptions added tens to a few hundred million tonnes, not orders of magnitude more than human totals [5][8][2].
3. Where the “10,000 times” figure fails: scale, time and provenance
The 10,000× claim conflates disparate metrics: it implies a single eruption outpacing “all human activity throughout history,” a cumulative figure that would be many hundreds to thousands of gigatons; no modern eruption approaches those cumulative human emissions, and authoritative fact‑checks and scientific syntheses conclude volcanic CO2 is a small fraction — often cited as less than 1–3% of current anthropogenic emissions annually, and overall human emissions over the industrial era far exceed typical volcanic outputs [1][9][3].
4. The scientific caveat: ancient supereruptions and long-term geologic sources
Scientists note exceptions on geological timescales: supervolcanic events and large igneous provinces in Earth’s deep past released vast amounts of CO2 over thousands of years and have been implicated in past climate shifts and extinctions, but these are extremely rare and not representative of present‑day volcanic activity [10][7]. Contemporary monitoring and multiple independent inventories (USGS, Deep Carbon Observatory, NASA analyses) consistently find that modern volcanism does not rival the scale or continuity of anthropogenic CO2 releases [7][11][5].
5. Why the meme persists and what to watch for in reporting
The viral myth benefits from intuitive drama (eruptions are spectacular) and from rhetorical tactics that compare instantaneous eruption rates to cumulative human emissions without context; fact‑checkers and scientific outlets have repeatedly debunked specific social‑media posts claiming volcanoes “produce more CO2 than humans,” noting that such claims misrepresent scientific estimates and downplay the steady, accumulating nature of fossil‑fuel emissions [1][3][12]. Readers should favor sources that compare consistent metrics (annual to annual, cumulative to cumulative) and heed the consensus of USGS, NOAA, NASA and peer‑reviewed syntheses that place anthropogenic emissions many tens to a hundred times above modern volcanic CO2 output [13][5][7].