How many traffic accidents involve undocumented immigrants with CDL licenses annually?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
There is no authoritative, published annual count of traffic accidents specifically involving undocumented immigrants who hold commercial driver’s licenses (CDLs) because federal crash reporting systems do not track driver immigration status; the FMCSA and NHTSA collect detailed crash and driver-license data but not national accident counts by immigration status [1]. What reporting does offer are isolated tallies, agency statements and estimates — for example, the DOT/Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) identified at least five fatal crashes in 2025 involving non‑domiciled CDL holders, a tiny share of total fatal truck crashes but not a comprehensive annual total [1] [2].
1. Why the precise annual number doesn’t exist: data systems and privacy limits
The principal federal data sets used to analyze large‑vehicle crashes — the FMCSA’s and NHTSA’s Large Truck and Bus Crash Facts and related FARS/FIRES feeds — do not include a consistent field for immigration status, so researchers cannot produce a validated national count of accidents involving undocumented CDL holders from those sources alone [1]. Academic and policy researchers therefore rely on proxies, case compilations, audits and state‑level anecdotes rather than a centralized statistic; several outlets and law firms explicitly note that agencies “do not systematically track or report crash rates by driver national origin or immigration status” [1].
2. What the fragments of evidence show: small counts, targeted examples, and estimates of the population at risk
Federal and media accounts have highlighted a handful of high‑profile fatal crashes involving non‑domiciled or foreign‑born CDL holders — the DOT referenced five fatal crashes since the start of 2025 when announcing emergency rule changes [1] [2] — while FMCSA audits have documented roughly 200,000 non‑domiciled CDL holders and 20,000 non‑domiciled CLP (commercial learner’s permit) holders in the U.S., figures that capture documented non‑domiciled drivers but do not include unknown undocumented drivers [2]. Putting the five identified fatal crashes in context, one report noted 1,600 fatal truck crashes through July 2025, meaning those five accounted for about 0.31 percent of that mid‑year total — a useful snapshot but not an annualized, representative measure [1].
3. Conflicting narratives and contested inferences
Policy actors and some media have used the handful of fatal crashes to argue for broad rule changes and immigration enforcement of CDL eligibility, while critics and independent reporters caution that the evidence base is thin and that targeting foreign‑born drivers may conflate nationality with qualification or training gaps [3]. Academic studies on licensing reforms and crash outcomes show mixed results: some papers estimate small increases in county‑level fatal crashes after granting licenses to undocumented drivers (about 0.46 additional fatal crashes per county annually in one analysis), but these studies address licensing policy effects broadly and do not isolate commercial CDL holders or produce national counts of accidents among undocumented CDL drivers [4] [5].
4. Practical realities for counting and policymaking
Because law enforcement sweeps and immigration arrests (for example, ICE operations that have arrested more than 100 truck drivers in a California operation) produce episodic case lists rather than a complete accident census, advocates on all sides are left stitching together incidents, audits and local prosecutions to make policy arguments [6]. Independent commentators and advocacy groups also produce disparate figures — some amplifying worst‑case estimates about undocumented truckers and fatalities that are not traceable to national crash data — underscoring that the debate often mixes verified agency tallies with conjecture and advocacy claims [7].
Conclusion: the direct answer
No definitive annual number can be produced from available federal and academic sources because the national crash databases do not record driver immigration status; the best available, verifiable statements are incident counts and audits (for example, FMCSA’s identification of at least five fatal crashes involving non‑domiciled CDL holders in 2025 and the FMCSA audit figure of roughly 200,000 non‑domiciled CDL holders), which illustrate the issue’s salience but stop short of an annualized accident total [1] [2]. Policymakers and reporters who seek a single national figure would first need either a change in federal reporting fields or a coordinated, privacy‑sensitive data‑matching effort across DMV, FMCSA and immigration records — neither of which exists in the public record cited here [1] [3].