Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: Which English cities and towns have the highest Muslim percentages (e.g., Bradford, Birmingham, London boroughs)?
Executive Summary
The strongest, consistent finding across the supplied analyses is that London’s Tower Hamlets, and northern cities such as Bradford and Birmingham, rank among the English local areas with the highest proportions of Muslim residents, with Tower Hamlets reported at about 39.9% and Bradford and Birmingham each around 30% in 2021 Census breakdowns [1] [2] [3]. The datasets and summaries agree that large cities and specific London boroughs host the largest Muslim shares by percentage and absolute numbers, while national-level analyses underscore that Muslims make up a growing share of the population concentrated in particular local authorities and some of the most deprived districts [4] [5]. Below I extract the core claims, compare the figures and framing across sources, and identify where the accounts converge or diverge and what important context is omitted.
1. What the claims actually say — Tallies and percentages that anchor the debate
The collected analyses assert that Tower Hamlets has the highest Muslim percentage in England (around 39.9%), and that Bradford and Birmingham each have Muslim shares around 30%, placing them among the highest-ranking cities for Muslim proportion [1] [2] [3]. Several summaries list top places by absolute Muslim population—Birmingham, Bradford, Tower Hamlets, Manchester, and Newham appear in top-five lists—with Birmingham singled out for the largest absolute Muslim population [6] [7] according to one tabulation [4]. The sources present two distinct but related metrics: percentage of local population who are Muslim, where Tower Hamlets leads by proportion, and absolute counts where Birmingham leads by total Muslim residents [4] [1].
2. How sources agree — Convergence on the headline places and census basis
All usable sources that supply figures tie their claims to the 2021 Census or post-census summaries and analyses, and they consistently name Tower Hamlets, Bradford, Birmingham, Newham, and Blackburn with Darwen among the local authorities with large Muslim shares [1] [4] [2]. The highest-percentage claimant—Tower Hamlets at roughly 39.9% Muslim—is repeated in multiple summaries and framed as the standout example of a London borough with a concentrated Muslim population [1]. The Census-rooted tabulations also consistently show a national increase in the Muslim population share since 2011 and place a considerable share of the Muslim population in a relatively small set of local authorities, reinforcing the geographic concentration narrative [5].
3. Where the sources differ — Percentages, absolute counts, and labeling of “cities” vs local authorities
Differences arise in emphasis and framing. Some analyses list top cities by absolute Muslim numbers, e.g., Birmingham with 341,811, which highlights urban scale and service needs, while others emphasize percentage share, which spotlights local demographic dominance such as Tower Hamlets’ near-40% figure [4] [1]. Another divergence is terminology: certain pieces refer loosely to “cities and towns” while underlying data are organized by local authority areas and London boroughs, which can conflate city-level boundaries and administrative units [8] [9]. The Henry Jackson Society table referenced supplies a constituency-level lens but is noted as not directly supplying the specific city breakdowns in the provided extract, illustrating different geographic units across sources [9].
4. What the numbers leave out — Socioeconomic context and temporal dynamics
The extracts note but do not fully unpack crucial context: a substantial share of the Muslim population lives in more deprived local authority districts, and Muslim population growth is uneven across areas [5]. The supplied summaries do not provide age structures, migration versus birth-driven growth contrasts, or time-series mapping beyond 2011–2021 changes, yet these factors materially shape public-service planning, electoral implications, and community life. Moreover, concentration by percentage does not equal homogeneity of experience; borough- or city-level averages mask intra-area diversity in socioeconomic status, country of origin, religious practice, and generational differences, a nuance missing from the top-line lists [5].
5. Bottom line: What a careful reader should take away
A reader should conclude that Tower Hamlets stands out by percentage share, while Birmingham leads by absolute numbers, and Bradford, Newham, Blackburn with Darwen and Manchester are repeatedly identified among places with high Muslim presence according to 2021 Census-derived reporting [1] [4] [2]. The provided sources agree on the broad pattern of geographic concentration and recent population increase, but they differ in metric choice and administrative unit, and they omit finer socioeconomic and intra-area differentiation that would change policy-relevant interpretation [5] [9]. For operational questions—service provision, electoral analysis, or community engagement—both percentage and absolute counts and local socioeconomic data are necessary to convert these headline rankings into actionable insight [5].