What percentage of Minnesota’s Somali population are naturalized U.S. citizens versus noncitizens?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Census-based reporting shows about 58% of Minnesota’s Somali population were born in the U.S., and of the foreign‑born Somalis in Minnesota roughly 87% are naturalized U.S. citizens, leaving a relatively small share as noncitizens among the foreign‑born cohort (AP, CNN, PBS, KTTC) [1] [2] [3] [4].
1. What the numbers mean: birthplace versus citizenship
The most-cited figure across local and national outlets is that almost 58% of Minnesota’s Somalis are U.S.-born; that number describes birthplace and therefore automatic citizenship at birth, not naturalization status [4] [1] [3]. Separately, reporters who examined the foreign‑born subset find that roughly 87% of foreign‑born Somalis in Minnesota have become naturalized citizens — a different slice of the population that excludes the U.S.-born majority [2] [4] [3].
2. How to translate the two percentages into the broader population
Taken together, the data imply that a majority of Minnesota’s Somali community are U.S. citizens, either by birth (about 58%) or by naturalization among the foreign‑born (about 87% of that subgroup). Available sources do not provide a single, precise breakdown that converts those two percentages into an exact share of total Somalis who are naturalized versus noncitizen; reporters instead present the figures as complementary facts about birthplace and naturalization within the foreign‑born population [4] [1] [2].
3. Estimates of the noncitizen population and gaps in reporting
Several outlets emphasize that only a minority of Minnesota’s Somali residents are noncitizens. One local report cites an estimate from the state demographer that about 5,800 Somalis in Minnesota are not citizens, but that figure is presented as a state estimate rather than as part of the Census‑derived percentages [5]. Public reporting does not provide a universally agreed, source‑linked percentage of total Somalis who are noncitizens; available sources do not present a single Census table that yields the exact share of all Somalis who are noncitizens [5] [4].
4. What the 87% naturalization figure actually covers
News organizations repeatedly attribute the 87% naturalization figure to Census-derived American Community Survey analysis describing the foreign‑born Somali population in Minnesota; that stat means 87% of foreign‑born Somalis report being naturalized, not that 87% of all Somalis in the state are naturalized [2] [3] [4]. Multiple outlets (AP, CNN, PBS, KTTC, Fox9) use the same framing, indicating broad agreement in contemporary reporting sources [1] [2] [3] [4] [6].
5. Why these distinctions matter in policy and public debate
Officials and commentators discussing enforcement or deportation plans have sometimes conflated immigration status with community size; the dual facts — a majority born in the U.S. and a high naturalization rate among the foreign‑born — undermine blanket characterizations that the community is primarily undocumented [7] [8]. Reporting from multiple outlets underscores that most Minnesota Somalis are citizens and therefore not subject to deportation for immigration status alone [1] [3].
6. Competing perspectives and possible motives in coverage
Mainstream outlets (AP, CNN, PBS, KTTC, Fox9) highlight the high citizenship rates as a corrective to political claims targeting Somalis [1] [2] [3] [4] [6]. Opinion and partisan outlets amplify fraud cases or prosecutorial counts that disproportionately involve Somali defendants; those pieces stress criminal allegations and sometimes imply community‑wide culpability [9]. Readers should note those different framings and the likely political stakes: citizenship data are used both to defend the community and to contest enforcement priorities [7] [9].
7. Limitations and what reporting does not say
Available sources do not provide a direct, single percentage that splits Minnesota’s entire Somali population into naturalized citizens vs. noncitizens; instead they supply (a) percent U.S.-born (~58%) and (b) percent naturalized within the foreign‑born (~87%). Exact counts and an overall noncitizen percentage for the full Somali population are not published in the supplied reporting and would require the underlying ACS cross‑tabulations or state demographer tables not included in these stories [4] [5].
8. Bottom line for readers
Multiple reputable news outlets report the same core facts: a majority of Minnesota’s Somali community were born in the U.S. (about 58%), and among foreign‑born Somalis about 87% are naturalized citizens — together indicating that most Minnesotan Somalis are U.S. citizens, and only a minority are noncitizens according to the available reporting [4] [1] [2] [3].