Did muhammed make love to a 9 year old?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Was this fact-check helpful?
1. Summary of the results
The claim that Muhammad made love to a 9-year-old is a topic of significant debate and controversy, with various sources presenting different perspectives on the issue [1]. Some analyses suggest that the claim of Muhammad marrying a 9-year-old is without foundation and is an eighth-century historical fabrication, citing a doctoral thesis that concludes the hadith was fabricated 'whole cloth' by a narrator named Hisham ibn Urwa [1]. Other sources argue that the controversy surrounding Aisha's age at marriage is a manufactured one, and that the age of marriage varies across cultures and time periods, making it unfair to judge a 1400-year-old society with modern standards [2]. Additionally, some sources present various evidences from hadiths and historical sources to argue that Aisha was likely 18 or 19 years old at the time of her marriage, rather than 9, and that the hadith suggesting she was 9 is discrepant and defective [3].
2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints
A key missing context in the original statement is the historical and cultural context of the time, which is highlighted by several sources as being essential to understanding the issue [2]. Alternative viewpoints include the idea that the controversy surrounding Aisha's age at marriage is a manufactured one, and that the age of marriage varies across cultures and time periods [2]. Another alternative viewpoint is that Aisha was likely 18 or 19 years old at the time of her marriage, rather than 9, and that the hadith suggesting she was 9 is discrepant and defective [3]. Furthermore, some sources highlight the need for intellectual honesty and humility in interfaith discussions, and argue that the accusation of pedophilia against Muhammad is a recent development without historical precedent [4].
3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement
The original statement may be considered misleading or biased, as it presents a claim that is not supported by all sources, and does not provide the necessary historical and cultural context [1]. Some sources benefit from this framing, as it allows them to present a narrative that is critical of Muhammad and Islam [1]. On the other hand, other sources benefit from a more nuanced and contextualized understanding of the issue, as it allows them to present a more balanced and accurate narrative [2] [3]. Ultimately, it is essential to approach this topic with intellectual honesty and humility, and to consider multiple perspectives and sources before forming a conclusion [4] [2] [2].