Fact check: Both Will Levis and Anthony's my Richardson were bad in 2024. Why is the narrative that Levis is a bist but Anthony Richardson needs more time?

1. Summary of the results

The raw statistics show that both quarterbacks have indeed struggled in 2024, with both having concerning metrics. Will Levis has played more games ^[1] with 339/556 completions, 3,899 yards, 21 TDs, and 16 INTs, while Richardson has played 15 games with 176/348 completions, 2,391 yards, 11 TDs, and 13 INTs ^[2]. Both quarterbacks have posted some of the worst metrics in the league, including bottom-five passer ratings and poor interception rates ^[3].

2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints

Several important contextual factors are missing from the original statement:

• Team Circumstances: The Colts still maintain a long-shot chance at the postseason, while Levis's team has no playoff hopes and he has been benched ^[3]. This difference in team situations likely influences public perception and patience levels.
• Historical Context: The situation draws parallels to the 2011 draft quarterbacks Jake Locker and Blaine Gabbert, suggesting this isn't unprecedented for highly drafted quarterbacks to struggle early ^[3].
• Systemic Patterns: There is documented evidence of racial bias in NFL quarterback draft evaluations from 2010-2022, showing systematic undervaluation of Black quarterbacks despite superior performance metrics ^[4]. However, recent years have seen successful Black quarterbacks like Mahomes, Jackson, and Stroud being highly drafted ^[5].

3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement

The original statement oversimplifies a complex situation by:

• Ignoring Statistical Context: While both quarterbacks have struggled, Levis has actually produced slightly better overall numbers with higher completion volume and more touchdowns ^[2].
• Racial Undertones: The different narratives surrounding these quarterbacks may be influenced by historical patterns of racial bias in quarterback evaluation ^[4], though the NFL has shown progress in this area with recent successful Black quarterback draft picks ^[5].
• Team Context: The statement fails to acknowledge that Richardson's team still has playoff hopes, which naturally leads to more patience from fans and media, while Levis has been benched on a non-contending team ^[3].