Similarities between ice and the Gestapo
Comparisons between U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and Nazi Germany’s Gestapo are frequent, emotionally charged, and serve as both warning and rhetorical weapon; historians and comment...
Your fact-checks will appear here
Official secret police of Nazi Germany
Comparisons between U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and Nazi Germany’s Gestapo are frequent, emotionally charged, and serve as both warning and rhetorical weapon; historians and comment...
Comparing under to the Sturmabteilung (SA, “Brownshirts”) is a charged analogy that reflects deep political alarm, and the reporting shows both proponents of the comparison and strong pushback; advoca...
The claim that U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is “like the Gestapo” compresses a complex set of facts, historical analogies, and moral judgments into a single inflammatory comparison t...
Historians and legal scholars disagree about whether Adolf Hitler “enforced gun control” in a simple, monolithic way: the Weimar Republic had strict firearms rules beginning in 1928 that enabled regis...
Most Germans did not mount widespread public protests against the Nazi death camps, but there were important, documented exceptions where Germans—often in specific social circumstances—did openly resi...
Yes — and their collaborators did carry out door-to-door searches, arrests and roundups at various times and for multiple purposes, particularly in the early consolidation of power and during the pers...
A single, sober reason to believe an ordinary person will not be abducted or killed by ICE is that ICE remains a bounded federal law‑enforcement agency operating under statutes, oversight and limits t...
The Catholic Church’s response to Nazi persecution was complex and mixed: institutional leaders sometimes protested Nazi attacks on the Church and issued public condemnations (notably the 1937 encycli...
Adolf Hitler, as the leader of Nazi Germany, committed profound wrongs by orchestrating the Holocaust, which systematically murdered six million Jews and millions of others, and by initiating World Wa...
Public protest by Germans against Nazi concentration and extermination policies during World War II existed but was extremely limited, localized, and atypical; the best-documented example is the Rosen...
publicly rebuked Gov. Tim Walz for likening the fear of some Minnesota children amid to ’s experience, calling the comparison “deeply offensive” and saying “Anne Frank was targeted and murdered solely...
Historians generally warn that institutions with the or risks flattening complex history and trivializing unique crimes of , even as they acknowledge such analogies reveal genuine public anxieties abo...
Historians agree that the annihilation of Lidice and Ležáky was a direct Nazi reprisal after Operation Anthropoid, but they remain divided about how specifically the assassination caused those two vil...
The event most commonly linked to a “German assassination that started WWII” is the Gleiwitz incident — a false‑flag attack staged by Nazi operatives on the radio station at Gleiwitz (now Gliwice) on ...
Between 1933 and 1945 the systematically sought to subordinate, co‑opt, marginalize and, in many cases, annihilate religious communities that conflicted with its racial and political ideology; it comb...
Surviving Nazi security and police records relevant to the reprisals after Reinhard Heydrich’s assassination are primarily preserved among captured RSHA/Gestapo files that were taken by Allied authori...
Comparisons that liken modern U.S. law enforcement to totalitarian secret police — the Gestapo, NKVD/KGB, SAVAK or the Stasi — are commonly used to express fear about coercive tactics, but scholars wa...
Gestapo archival reporting—reproduced in postwar histories and reference works—recorded that investigators briefly suspected Lidice because several Czechoslovak army officers exiled in Britain had ori...
The claim that current operations are “the same as Hitler and ” is historically and factually inaccurate: the was a secret police with a mandate to eliminate political dissent and enable genocide unde...
Most historians treat as a paradigmatic case of Nazi collective reprisal carried out on flimsy or manufactured grounds: contemporary accounts and major institutions emphasize that there was no solid e...