Index/People/William J. Benson

William J. Benson

Fact-Checks

5 results
Dec 9, 2025
Most Viewed

Have courts ever challenged the validity of the 16th Amendment based on how it was proposed and ratified?

Federal courts have repeatedly rejected challenges that the Sixteenth Amendment was invalidly proposed or ratified; courts treat the Archivist/Secretary of State’s certification and subsequent judicia...

Dec 11, 2025
Most Viewed

Did any states object to the ratification process of the 16th Amendment and how many state ratifications were required?

The Sixteenth Amendment required ratification by three‑quarters of the states — 36 of the 48 then in the Union — and that threshold was reached in early February 1913 when the 36th state ratified; Sec...

Feb 1, 2026
Most Viewed

Which 36 states ratified the Sixteenth Amendment and on what dates did each ratify?

, proposed by in 1909, was ratified by the legislatures of thirty-six states between 1909 and early 1913 and was proclaimed part of the Constitution in February 1913 . The official documentary record ...

Feb 7, 2026

What is the documentary evidence Secretary of State Knox used to proclaim the Sixteenth Amendment ratified on February 25, 1913?

’s February 25, 1913 proclamation that the had been ratified rested not on a single parchment but on ’s file of “official documents” — the ratification resolutions sent by — a record Knox explicitly c...

Feb 1, 2026

What legal arguments have tax protesters used to challenge the Sixteenth Amendment and how have courts ruled?

Tax protesters have mounted several recurring challenges to the — principally that it was never properly ratified or that it does not authorize taxation of individual income — but federal courts and t...