Index/Topics/Goldwater Rule Debate

Goldwater Rule Debate

The Goldwater Rule and its application to public figures like Donald Trump, with Dr. Bandy X. Lee's warnings sparking debate.

Fact-Checks

8 results
Jan 17, 2026
Most Viewed

What does the Goldwater Rule say about diagnosing public figures, and how has it been applied to Trump?

The Goldwater Rule, adopted by the American Psychiatric Association (APA) in 1973, forbids psychiatrists from offering professional diagnoses of public figures whom they have not personally examined a...

Jan 15, 2026
Most Viewed

How do psychologists apply the Goldwater rule when assessing public figures like presidents?

The Goldwater Rule is an ethical constraint that discourages psychiatrists and, in practice, many psychologists from offering professional diagnoses of living public figures they have not personally e...

Jan 17, 2026
Most Viewed

What is the Goldwater Rule and how has it shaped psychiatric commentary on public figures?

The Goldwater Rule is an APA ethics annotation—Section 7.3—adopted in 1973 that forbids psychiatrists from offering professional opinions about the mental health of public figures they have not person...

Jan 21, 2026

What evidence have 'duty to warn' psychiatrists presented publicly about Trump's behavior since 2017?

A loose coalition of psychiatrists and psychologists—often calling themselves “duty to warn” or led by figures like Bandy Lee and John Gartner—have publicly pointed to patterns in Donald Trump’s publi...

Jan 19, 2026

How have professional psychiatric organizations other than the APA responded to the Goldwater Rule during political crises?

Professional psychiatric organizations outside the American Psychiatric Association have not presented a single, unified stance on the Goldwater Rule during political crises; responses range from expl...

Jan 18, 2026

What is the Goldwater rule and how does it apply today?

The Goldwater rule is an ethical guideline adopted by the American Psychiatric Association in 1973 that forbids psychiatrists from offering professional opinions about public figures they have not per...

Jan 18, 2026

What legal consequences, if any, arise when a clinician publicly diagnoses a public figure without examination?

A clinician publicly diagnosing a living public figure without an examination primarily breaches professional ethics rather than creating a clear-cut new criminal offense; the dominant sanction is pro...

Jan 18, 2026

Which professional organizations have issued statements about assessing public figures' mental fitness and what rules govern those statements?

Major U.S. professional bodies—most prominently the American Psychiatric Association—have formally limited their members from publicly diagnosing or declaring the mental fitness of public figures thro...