Index/Topics/Posse Comitatus

Posse Comitatus

The Posse Comitatus Act and its relation to the Insurrection Act, including the prohibition on using the military for domestic law enforcement.

Fact-Checks

14 results
Jan 18, 2026
Most Viewed

What evidence have courts required to determine whether National Guard units were under state or federal operational control?

Courts have focused on tangible indicia of who exercised command and control—legal status (Title 10 vs. Title 32), orders issued, chain-of-command communications, funding and mission definitions, and ...

Jan 16, 2026
Most Viewed

Can a US president invoke the Insurrection Act to arrest state officials?

The Insurrection Act authorizes the president to deploy federal armed forces and federalize National Guard units to suppress insurrections, enforce federal authority, or assist civilian authorities wh...

Jan 16, 2026
Most Viewed

What legal steps allow a U.S. president or governor to declare martial law during midterm elections?

A U.S. governor can, under state constitutions and statutes and historical practice, proclaim martial law within his or her state when faced with insurrection, invasion, or extreme civil disorder, sub...

Jan 28, 2026

How have state governors or National Guard commanders publicly described their preparations for federalization scenarios since 2024?

Since 2024, state governors and have framed “” not only as a legal shift in command but as a potential political and operational flashpoint: governors have publicly warned against unwanted transfers o...

Jan 25, 2026

How have courts interpreted the president’s authority under the Insurrection Act and emergency powers in recent decisions?

Recent judicial decisions have pushed back against executive claims of unchecked power under the and related emergency authorities, holding that presidential invocations are reviewable and limited by ...

Jan 16, 2026

Legality if Trump's actions in mn

The core legal question is whether President Trump can lawfully invoke the Insurrection Act, withhold federal funds, or otherwise deploy federal forces in Minnesota to suppress protests linked to ICE ...

Jan 15, 2026

What legal standards would courts apply if the president explicitly invoked the Insurrection Act in 2026?

If the president explicitly invoked the Insurrection Act in 2026, federal courts would apply a mix of statutory text, historic practice, constitutional limits, and evolving standards from recent refor...

Jan 13, 2026

How have governors used National Guard deployments to respond to federal immigration operations?

Governors have used the National Guard both to cooperate with and to resist federal immigration operations, leveraging different duty statuses, lawsuits, and public orders to shape outcomes . The resu...

Feb 4, 2026

How have U.S. courts historically ruled on presidential domestic military deployments under the Insurrection Act?

courts have historically granted presidents broad deference when they deploy military forces domestically under the , grounded in early precedent that left threshold judgments to the executive, yet ju...

Feb 2, 2026

did the President Trump say we're in a Civil War

has not been documented in the provided reporting as using the literal phrase "we're in a Civil War," but he has repeatedly framed political conflict in explicit wartime language—most notably calling ...

Jan 28, 2026

How have specific federal district court decisions ruled on President Trump’s 2025–2026 deployments under the Insurrection Act?

Federal district courts in , and rejected or enjoined elements of and related federalizations — finding either that statutory prerequisites for military or federalized-guard action were unmet or that ...

Jan 18, 2026

How does Title 32 funding differ from Title 10 federalization, and why does it matter legally?

Title 10 places National Guard members on federal active duty under presidential control and federal funding, while Title 32 keeps Guard members under state control but may be paid with federal dollar...

Jan 13, 2026

How does the federal Insurrection Act interact with gubernatorial National Guard activations?

The Insurrection Act is the narrow statutory bridge that permits the President to federalize state National Guard units or deploy active-duty forces for domestic law‑enforcement purposes in three spec...

Jan 10, 2026

Can a mayor or county sheriff request National Guard assistance locally?

Local leaders can and do ask for National Guard help, but the legal pathway, who controls the troops, and when they can be used depend on whether the Guard is serving under state or federal authority,...