Index/Topics/Prosecutorial Discretion

Prosecutorial Discretion

The broad discretion of federal prosecutors to decide whether to bring criminal charges.

Fact-Checks

9 results
Jan 17, 2026
Most Viewed

How did immigrant‑rights protests during the Obama years influence the creation and rollout of DACA and DAPA?

Immigrant-rights protests and advocacy during the Obama years helped create a political environment that elevated the plight of undocumented youth and pressured the administration to act after Congres...

Jan 17, 2026
Most Viewed

What is the historical track record of criminal contempt referrals from Congress and how often do they result in prosecution?

Criminal contempt referrals from Congress are a blunt tool that frequently end as political statements rather than criminal cases: since 2008 the House alone has held ten individuals in criminal conte...

Jan 18, 2026
Most Viewed

What specific evidence would a defendant need to prove selective prosecution in federal court?

To prevail on a federal selective-prosecution claim a defendant must produce clear, specific evidence showing the prosecution had a discriminatory effect — that similarly situated persons of a differe...

Jan 11, 2026

How do DHS referral policies and DOJ prosecutorial guidelines influence whether an individual is criminally charged or placed in civil removal proceedings?

DHS referral policies—formal guidance that ranks enforcement priorities and tells front‑line officers when to refer individuals into immigration court—largely determine who is routed into civil remova...

Feb 5, 2026

What legal standards govern when a U.S. Attorney can decline federal prosecution and how were they applied in the Epstein matter?

Federal prosecutors have broad, entrenched discretion to decide whether to bring criminal charges—subject to departmental policy, statutes like the Crime Victims’ Rights Act, and limits against improp...

Feb 3, 2026

What standards do law enforcement and newsrooms use to differentiate unverified tips from prosecutable evidence in large document releases?

treats large document dumps not as immediate prosecutable evidence but as raw leads that must be validated through contemporaneous documentation, chain-of-custody controls, and legal processes before ...

Feb 3, 2026

How did the Morton memos define enforcement tiers and how were they interpreted by field offices?

The memos established a tiered prioritization for that focused resources on national-security, border-security, and serious public-safety threats while encouraging the exercise of in lower-priority ca...

Jan 14, 2026

How did the Obama administration's use of prosecutorial discretion compare to the Trump administration's approach to deportation cases?

The Obama administration institutionalized prosecutorial discretion to focus removals on recent border crossers, national-security threats, and convicted serious criminals—reducing interior removals a...

Jan 9, 2026

How do ICE detention and prosecutorial referrals differ for criminal vs civil cases?

Immigration enforcement is formally a civil administrative system while criminal prosecution is a separate federal process, and that split drives how detention and referrals are handled: ICE uses civi...