Index/Topics/Wrongful detentions

Wrongful detentions

There have been cases of wrongful detentions and removals of U.S. citizens due to misidentification, biometric or database mismatches, and operational pressure.

Fact-Checks

8 results
Jan 14, 2026
Most Viewed

Is ICE illegally detaining people?

Recent reporting shows widespread controversy over ICE’s detention practices: federal judges and civil-rights groups say many detentions run counter to law or precedent and courts are increasingly rej...

Jan 11, 2026
Most Viewed

How many American citizens have been wrongly detained by ICE in 2025?

ProPublica’s investigative tally — compiled and reported by outlets including OPB and cited by legal blogs — identifies “more than 170” U.S. citizens who were held by immigration agents in 2025 . That...

Jan 11, 2026
Most Viewed

Do U.S. federal laws require noncitizens to carry or show ID to ICE agents in public?

Federal reporting and legal-aid guidance consistently state that adults with lawful immigration status are required by federal law to carry their immigration documents and that ICE may ask to see such...

Jan 10, 2026

What are ICE's jurisdictional limits regarding US citizens?

Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has no statutory authority to remove or deport U.S. citizens and its official policy asserts it does not arrest or detain citizens for immigration violations,...

Jan 28, 2026

Can U.S. citizens be legally deported by ICE?

No: as a matter of law, through civil immigration procedures, and policy recognizes that it lacks authority to “arrest and/or detain a U.S.” in . That legal rule, however, exists alongside a documente...

Jan 24, 2026

How many us citizens are currently in ice custody

There is no publicly reported, authoritative count of how many U.S. citizens are "currently" in custody in the materials reviewed; ICE and mainstream reporting provide totals for the detained populati...

Jan 10, 2026

What steps can enrolled tribal citizens take immediately if approached or detained by ICE?

When ICE approaches or detains an enrolled tribal citizen, immediate actions center on asserting U.S. citizenship with proper ID, remaining silent beyond basic identification, requesting to speak to a...

Jan 6, 2026

How does ICE identify citizenship status during arrests and processing?

Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) uses a layered approach—document review, database and record checks, and biometric matching—to determine whether someone in custody is a U.S. citizen, but pro...