What do excess‑mortality studies say about U.S. pandemic deaths in 2020–2022 compared with the official COVID death tallies?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Excess‑mortality studies — which compare observed all‑cause deaths to statistically modelled baselines — consistently find that the United States suffered substantially more deaths during 2020–2022 than were recorded as official COVID‑19 deaths, with most multi‑method estimates clustering around roughly one million excess deaths for March 2020–February 2022 and continued elevated excess mortality into 2022 [1] [2] [3]. The gap between excess deaths and death certificates assigned to COVID‑19 varies across places and time, reflecting a mix of uncounted COVID deaths, indirect pandemic effects, reporting lags, and local certification rules [4] [3] [5].
1. What excess‑mortality studies actually measure and why they matter
Excess‑mortality estimates subtract an expected baseline — derived from pre‑pandemic mortality trends and seasonal patterns — from observed all‑cause deaths to capture both direct SARS‑CoV‑2 deaths and indirect deaths caused or displaced by the pandemic, offering a less biased summary of overall mortality impact than cause‑of‑death certificates alone [6] [7].
2. How big was the gap nationwide, 2020–2022?
Multiple national and county‑level analyses find roughly one million excess deaths in the first two pandemic years: the CDC reported about 1.1 million excess deaths for March 2020–February 2022, county‑level work in Science Advances and related PNAS analyses yield estimates in the range of roughly 0.94–1.28 million excess deaths for 2020–2021 or March 2020–February 2022 depending on method and uncertainty bounds, and broader models through August 2022 estimate about 1.19 million excess natural‑cause deaths with a non‑trivial share not reported as COVID‑19 on death certificates [1] [2] [8] [3].
3. Where and when the mismatch was largest
The geographic picture is heterogeneous: early in the pandemic large metropolitan areas drove excess mortality, but by the second year the burden shifted toward nonmetro and Southern counties, and county‑level ratios of excess to reported COVID deaths vary substantially — some counties show many more excess deaths than reported COVID deaths while other counties report more COVID deaths than excess, a pattern that intensified in some regions between 2020 and 2021 [1] [4] [5].
4. Why excess deaths exceed official COVID counts — multiple plausible mechanisms
Researchers emphasize three overlapping explanations: unrecognized COVID‑19 deaths (misattribution on death certificates or lack of testing), indirect pandemic effects such as delayed care for chronic disease and mental‑health/substance‑use crises, and measurement artefacts including reporting lags or local rules that inflate or deflate COVID assignment; studies using natural‑cause excesses find temporal alignment in many counties between rises in non‑COVID excess deaths and later reported COVID deaths, supporting undercounting in some places while acknowledging real indirect effects in others [3] [7] [9] [5].
5. How the US compares internationally and across 2021–2022
Compared with peer high‑income countries the United States had higher COVID‑specific and excess all‑cause mortality in 2020 and into 2021, and while excess deaths fell about 10% from the first pandemic year to the second in U.S. estimates, the US still fared worse than many comparators through much of 2021–2022 before some narrowing in 2022 [10] [2] [11].
6. Limits and caveats: what excess estimates do not prove and where uncertainty remains
Excess mortality is sensitive to baseline choice, reporting completeness, and the treatment of non‑natural causes; CDC methods have been updated to stabilize baselines and provisional counts remain incomplete in places with long reporting lags, so point estimates have uncertainty ranges and regional interpretation requires caution — excess death ≠ automatic proof that every unassigned excess death was an uncounted COVID death [12] [6] [7].
7. Bottom line
Across independent studies and governmental dashboards, excess‑mortality work paints a consistent picture: the pandemic produced substantially more deaths in the United States in 2020–2022 than official COVID‑attributed counts alone indicate, with roughly on the order of a million excess deaths in the first two years and continued elevated mortality into 2022, and with the residual gap reflecting a mix of undercounting, indirect harms, and reporting issues that vary by place and time [1] [2] [3] [12].