Has law enforcement taken down or seized Brian's carding site in 2025?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
There is no clear, verifiable evidence in the provided reporting that law enforcement definitively seized or permanently took down Brian’s Club in 2025; contemporary sources document hacks, temporary disappearances and historical takdown claims from earlier years, but none of the items in the dossier confirm an official 2025 seizure or asset forfeiture by authorities [1] [2] [3].
1. A short history that explains why the question keeps resurfacing
Brian’s Club has long been among the most notorious carding “automated vending cart” marketplaces, repeatedly in the headlines after a major 2019 breach that dumped millions of card records and after subsequent hacks and leaks that exposed the site’s inventory to banks and researchers, and reporting across 2019–2025 frames the site as resilient and persistent rather than definitively shuttered [4] [5] [3].
2. Where reporting documents law‑enforcement seizures — and where Brian’s Club is not on that list
Several dark‑web markets have been publicly seized or disrupted by authorities in multi‑national operations — for example SSNDOB and Hydra and other marketplaces are explicitly described as subject to law enforcement seizures in industry writeups — but the provided sources that catalogue those takedowns do not assert that Brian’s Club itself was seized by police in 2025 [2] [6].
3. What the sources do document about Brian’s Club in 2025
Coverage from 2023–2025 and dark‑web market roundups depict Brian’s Club as a continuing node in the carding ecosystem, noting temporary disappearance and returns, large historical inventories of stolen cards, and fresh breaches where card data was exposed or re‑leaked — reporting that points to compromise and instability rather than an official, documented law‑enforcement seizure in 2025 [1] [2] [3] [7].
4. Why some outlets describe a “demise” and why that can mislead readers
Several pieces repeat claims that Brian’s Club “crumbled” or “was shut down,” often citing arrests or seizures in general terms or referencing older coordinated actions against underground markets; these narratives can conflate a successful hack of the site, the temporary removal of its onion address, or arrests of affiliated vendors with a formal government seizure of the platform, and the sources here show that such language is used inconsistently across blogs and retrospectives [8] [9] [10].
5. Interests and incentives shaping the record — who benefits from different framings
Security blogs, vendors and competitor criminal actors have incentives to hype takedowns (to promote their own services, to sow confusion, or to perform “hacking back” and publicize leaks), while law enforcement agencies may be cautious about publicizing ongoing investigations; the reporting collected shows suspiciously similar narratives recycled across secondary outlets and independent analyses, underscoring that some claims (particularly on blogs and Medium posts) are shaped by echoing accounts rather than primary seizure notices or official indictments [1] [9] [2].
6. What is unknown and the honest bottom line
None of the provided sources includes an authoritative government notice, court filing, or confirmed seizure banner explicitly showing Brian’s Club was taken down by law enforcement in 2025, and the record instead documents breaches, data leaks and temporary outages — therefore, based on the available reporting, it cannot be stated that law enforcement seized or permanently took down Brian’s Club in 2025; if an official seizure occurred outside these sources, it is not captured in this collection and remains unverified [2] [3] [4].