What differences exist between adoption, signature, and publication dates in EU lawmaking?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Adoption is the internal political decision by the institutions that a text is final; signature is the formal joint signing that marks interinstitutional agreement; publication in the Official Journal is the legal step that makes the act public and (usually) starts its legal effect or entry into force (publication follows signature) [1] [2] [3]. The ordinary legislative procedure ends when Parliament and Council conclude formal adoption; after adoption the act is signed by institutional leaders and then published in the Official Journal [4] [3].
1. What “adoption” means: the political green light
Adoption is the point at which the co‑legislators — normally the European Parliament and the Council — have agreed on a joint text and have completed the formal internal steps that make that agreement final; if they cannot agree the proposal fails and the procedure ends [4] [2]. Several sources stress that adoption happens within the ordinary legislative procedure (first, second or third reading) and is a prerequisite to any further formalities: only when the two institutions have concluded the formal adoption procedures is the file ready for signing [4] [3].
2. Why “signature” exists: performative confirmation of joint adoption
Signature is a short, ceremonial but legalised act: after agreement, the President of the European Parliament and a representative of the Council sign the adopted text to demonstrate the two co‑legislators have formally adopted the legal act in accordance with the Treaties (Article 297 TFEU cited by practice) [3]. The signature is not a second negotiation; it is the formal confirmation that the intra‑institutional adoption process has concluded and clears the way for publication [3] [1].
3. Publication: the legal step that makes the law known and effective
Publication in the Official Journal is the administrative and legal act that makes the adopted and signed text public and typically triggers its entry into force or specific transitional timetables set in the act itself [2]. The Commission and other EU institution pages consistently state that a proposal becomes law when Parliament and Council agree on a joint text and it is published in the Official Journal, underlining publication’s central legal role [2] [1].
4. Sequence and timing: adoption → signature → publication
EU practice follows a clear sequence: first the political adoption inside institutions, then the joint signature by the Presidents/representatives, and finally publication in the Official Journal [1] [3]. Sources note that after both institutions have concluded formal adoption procedures the act is submitted for signature and then published, which explains why “adopted” texts sometimes appear in institution agendas before they are legally binding [1] [3].
5. Practical consequences and why the distinctions matter
The differences matter for legal certainty and implementation: stakeholders monitor adoption to know the final policy outcome; signature signals final interinstitutional closure and publication determines when obligations and deadlines begin to run [2] [3]. If the Parliament and Council cannot agree, nothing is adopted and the file dies unless re‑proposed by the Commission, highlighting the decisive weight of the adoption stage [4].
6. Points of dispute and limits in public reporting
Available reporting is unanimous on the sequence and roles but leaves practical timing and exceptions under‑explained. For instance, sources explain adoption, signature and publication in general terms and use the ordinary legislative procedure as the main example; they do not provide exhaustive lists of exceptions (e.g., acts adopted by a single institution in specific Treaty cases) nor detailed timelines for how long between signature and publication in every case [4] [2] [3]. Available sources do not mention precise timelines for all types of acts or every Treaty exception.
7. Bottom line for practitioners and observers
Track adoption to know the negotiated substance; watch for the signature ceremony as formal interinstitutional closure; rely on the Official Journal publication to determine legal effect and start dates [1] [3] [2]. Where speed matters — compliance deadlines, entry into force or national transposition — only publication provides a clear legal marker [2].
Limitations: this summary uses institutional guidance and explanatory material on the ordinary legislative procedure; it does not attempt to cover every special procedure or rare Treaty exception beyond what the cited sources describe [4] [2].