What are the historical examples of violence in Christianity?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Christianity's history includes well-documented episodes of organized and sporadic violence—ranging from state-backed crusades and inquisitions to local pogroms, colonial massacres, and intra-Christian warfare—yet the tradition also contains persistent streams of pacifism and theological debate about the legitimacy of force [1] [2] [3] [4]. The pattern is complex: early Christian nonresistance yielded, after Constantine, to theological justifications for coercion that were enacted unevenly across time and place [1] [5].
1. From persecuted sect to imperial partner: the Constantinian shift and the theory of just war
When Christianity moved from a persecuted minority to the religion of empire beginning with Constantine, Christian leaders and theologians began to rethink nonviolence; Augustine’s just-war formulations and the church’s new role in governance supplied moral frameworks that could legitimate force, turning what had often been private conscience into public coercion [1] [5] [6].
2. Crusades and holy war: organized military expeditions in the medieval period
The Crusades exemplify large-scale, theologically framed violence—launched with papal sanction in the late eleventh century and producing campaigns that included massacres in the Levant and Europe, and long-term interreligious conflict—historians interpret these wars as enabled by a theology that redefined some violence as morally neutral or sanctified [1] [2] [4].
3. Reconquista, forced conversions and violence toward Muslims and Jews in Iberia
In Iberia the Reconquista and its aftermath involved expulsion, forced conversion, and persecution of Muslim and Jewish communities after centuries of convivencia; scholars and contemporary commentators trace the uprooting of populations and legal-social penalties during the 15th–17th centuries to Christianizing political projects [7] [2].
4. Inquisitions, heresy trials and the suppression of dissent
From episcopal courts to papal inquisitions, Church institutions prosecuted suspected heretics, employing torture, imprisonment and executions across centuries; mainstream estimates place tens of thousands processed by ecclesiastical courts in the medieval and early modern eras, with many tortured and over a thousand executed in particular periods, and later witch trials and persecutions amplifying those costs [3] [5] [8].
5. Christian-on-Christian violence: schisms, crusades against fellow Christians, and the Fourth Crusade
Violence within Christianity—whether between Catholic and Orthodox Christians, Catholics and heretical movements like the Cathars, or Protestant and Catholic combatants in the wars of religion—was a persistent feature; the Fourth Crusade’s sack of Constantinople and the Albigensian Crusade against Cathars are highlighted in the sources as instances where doctrinal and political aims produced fratricidal violence [2] [9] [8].
6. Colonialism, conquest and the New World: faith and brutality in expansion
European expansion carried Christian actors into the Americas and elsewhere, where conquistadors and colonial regimes used religious language to justify conquest and subjugation of indigenous peoples; commentators link these campaigns to missionary entanglement with imperial violence and the large death tolls associated with conquest and slavery [10] [3].
7. Modern continuities and contested legacies: domestic violence, vigilantism, and spiritual warfare
Violence framed in Christian terms did not end with the Middle Ages: modern examples include extremist groups and lone actors invoking scripture, attacks framed as “spiritual warfare” (for example, violence against abortion clinics), and intra-Christian abuses; modern scholarship stresses both the misuse of Christian symbols and the ongoing debates within theology about when, if ever, violence is legitimate [4] [6].
8. Contexts, debates and gaps in the record
Scholars point out crucial qualifications: violence was uneven, often entangled with political, social, and economic motives, and Christian texts were interpreted in radically different ways across time; existing sources emphasize that counting victims and assigning sole causation to “Christianity” oversimplifies a complex nexus of empire, culture, and theology—sources also note historiographical blind spots, particularly in global and intra-Christian contexts [8] [11] [6].