Index/People/Ashcroft

Ashcroft

Family name

Fact-Checks

32 results
Jan 24, 2026
Most Viewed

How are courts treating AI‑generated or indistinguishable synthetic CSAM under current federal and state laws?

Federal courts and lawmakers are wrestling with (CSAM): prosecutors treat such material as criminal under existing federal statutes in many cases, but constitutional limits from and recent district-co...

Nov 12, 2025
Most Viewed

Does 18 U.S.C. §2256 include AI-generated images of minors as CSAM?

Federal statute 18 U.S.C. §2256 is broadly interpreted by federal agencies and many legal commentators to cover , but legal uncertainty remains for purely synthetic images not tied to real children. T...

Dec 10, 2025
Most Viewed

Have any court cases challenged arrests based on AI system reports of CSAM?

Federal prosecutors have charged people for creating, distributing, or possessing AI-generated CSAM, and at least one defendant successfully won dismissal of a possession count on First Amendment grou...

Dec 8, 2025

Have prosecutors used AI-chatbot confessions as evidence in CSAM cases?

Prosecutors have begun using AI-chatbot logs and other AI-related digital traces as evidence in criminal cases outside of CSAM prosecutions, and reporting shows growing legal and policy activity aroun...

Jan 22, 2026

What legal standards determine when AI‑generated sexual imagery of minors becomes criminal CSAM?

criminalizes many forms of when the image depicts a minor engaged in sexually explicit conduct or is “virtually indistinguishable” from such a depiction, but enforcement hinges on several legal thresh...

Jan 26, 2026

How have U.S. courts ruled on possession charges for AI‑generated CSAM and what precedents exist for First Amendment defenses?

A recent federal district court dismissed a possession charge tied to wholly AI‑generated obscene images, finding Section 1466A unconstitutional as applied to private possession of virtual CSAM—invoki...

Jan 17, 2026

How is textual only content depicting minors in sexual activities handled differently from visual content

Text-only sexual writing that depicts minors is treated far more permissively under U.S. law and constitutional doctrine than visual depictions: federal statutes and precedent focus criminal liability...

Jan 28, 2026

Is “cub art” illegal in the US?

— erotic or sexualized artwork depicting anthropomorphic juvenile animals (“cubs” or “babyfur”) — is not categorically illegal across the , but it occupies a volatile legal gray zone where specific fo...

Jan 12, 2026

Do any US states criminalize mere possession or viewing of child sexual abuse material without intent to distribute?

Yes. Federal law makes possession and even “access with intent to view” child sexual abuse material (CSAM) a crime (18 U.S.C. §§2252, 2252A), and state laws overwhelmingly criminalize possession and o...

Jan 29, 2026

What evidence and expert testimony do prosecutors use to show AI‑generated images are "virtually indistinguishable" from real CSAM?

Prosecutors seeking to demonstrate that (AIG‑CSAM) is "virtually indistinguishable" from real CSAM rely on a combination of published technical reports, frontline analyst testimony about visual indist...

Jan 12, 2026

What First Amendment defenses have been raised against deepfake and AI-generated sexual content laws?

Courts and scholars defending deepfake and AI-generated sexual content against statutory bans have mainly invoked core First Amendment doctrines: that synthetic expression is speech, content-based res...

Nov 11, 2025

Have courts ruled on defenses for accidental child pornography viewing?

Courts have addressed defenses for accidental or inadvertent viewing or possession of child pornography, with judicial rulings and legal commentary repeatedly emphasizing that for many child‑pornograp...

Jan 4, 2026

How has the PROTECT Act of 2003 been applied in prosecutions involving animated or drawn depictions of minors?

The PROTECT Act of 2003 has been used to prosecute cases involving animated or drawn depictions of minors primarily by criminalizing “obscene” virtual child pornography and images that are “virtually ...

Jan 30, 2026

How do U.S. courts interpret the PROTECT Act when applied to drawn or animated sexual material?

The makes drawn or animated sexual depictions of minors prosecutable under federal law when they meet either a “computer-generated indistinguishable” standard or are found to be obscene under 18 U.S.C...

Jan 29, 2026

What did Ashcroft v. Free Speech Coalition decide about virtual child pornography and why?

The in v. struck down parts of the that criminalized “virtual child pornography” — images that appear to depict minors but were produced without using real children — holding that those provisions wer...

Jan 27, 2026

How have courts treated prosecutions for possession-only CSAM where the defendant claims the images were AI-generated or virtual?

Federal and lower courts are starting to draw a sharp line between AI- or computer-generated sexual images that do not involve real children and material that is based on or depicts actual minors, wit...

Jan 23, 2026

What federal statutes and case law most directly address “indistinguishable” computer‑generated child pornography?

Federal law treats computer‑generated images that are "indistinguishable" from real children as through the definitional backbone in 18 U.S.C. § 2256 and through prosecutorial statutes such as 18 U.S....

Jan 21, 2026

How have federal appellate courts ruled in major hyperlink and cloud‑storage child‑pornography cases since 2010?

have split along lines of technology and mens rea: circuits have generally upheld prosecutions based on hyperlinks and active stings while taking a more cautious approach where possession depends on ,...

Jan 19, 2026

What standards do courts require to validate AI-assisted CSAM detection before it can support a warrant?

Courts demand that AI-assisted CSAM detection meet traditional evidence and Fourth Amendment standards: reliable methodology, known error rates and validation, transparent chain-of-custody and human c...

Jan 6, 2026

Is it illegal to create and save AI generated simulated csam on a private computer, if the images don't resemble anyone in real life, and are cartoony in nature?

Creating, distributing, or possessing AI-generated child sexual abuse material (CSAM) has been treated as illegal by many federal agencies and advocates, but key constitutional and statutory nuances m...