Your fact-checks will appear here
Family name
U.S. citizens who are wrongfully arrested or detained by ICE have multiple legal avenues—administrative claims under the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA), civil-rights suits (including challenges under ...
A modest but growing record of plaintiffs forcing monetary relief from ICE exists: community groups and individual U.S. citizens have won settlements such as a $150,000 payment to Brian Bukle for an u...
Federal courts and advocacy groups produced a string of notable 2025 rulings and filings challenging ICE and Border Patrol practices as violative of the Fourth Amendment and related due-process protec...
Federal courts in 2024–2025 increasingly rebuked ICE practices that led to the wrongful detention of U.S. citizens, imposing limits on warrantless arrests, detainer practices, and some mandatory-deten...
Federal courts have repeatedly found specific U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) practices unconstitutional or unlawful, particularly when those practices relied on error-prone databases, ...
There is no definitive number in the provided reporting that counts how many U.S. citizens have filed lawsuits against ICE for wrongful detention since 2020; available sources document multiple indivi...
In 2025, at least one major lawsuit brought against Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) by U.S.-based plaintiffs resulted in a nationwide settlement: Gonzalez v. ICE, a class-action that imposed...
A small but growing body of federal court rulings has produced enforceable remedies and injunctions against ICE practices that have led to the wrongful detention of U.S. citizens, most prominently the...
Yes. Multiple class actions have produced settlements or judgments restricting ICE practices alleged to violate the Fourth Amendment — most prominently Gonzalez v. ICE, which resulted in a five‑year c...
You can and people and groups have sued ICE in federal court for unlawful detention, using approaches like class actions, habeas petitions, Fourth Amendment and due-process claims, and Federal Tort Cl...
The Fourth Amendment limits unreasonable searches and seizures, and courts have increasingly scrutinized ICE arrest practices—especially detainers and courthouse arrests—as potentially unconstitutiona...
Federal courts since 2009 have repeatedly constrained ICE’s use of detainers, treating most detainers as non‑mandatory requests and requiring Fourth Amendment safeguards such as probable cause and not...
Federal courts in 2025–2025+ have repeatedly found specific ICE detention practices unconstitutional: courts have ruled ICE’s “automatic stay” use violated due process in more than 50 federal-district...
There were multiple notable legal developments in 2024–2025 touching on due process for immigrants arrested by ICE, most prominently a nationwide class-action settlement in Gonzalez v. ICE addressing ...
Federal law and agency policy allow ICE to make certain warrantless arrests under 8 U.S.C. §§ 1357 and 1226, but multiple 2025 federal court rulings and class settlements have sharply constrained that...
Courts over the last decade have produced a mix of rulings that both curb and scrutinize ICE authority, finding constitutional violations in practices like warrantless detentions and “knock-and-talk” ...
Federal courts in recent years have struck down several practices connected to home entries, detentions, and sweeps—notably district and circuit rulings that found arrests and detainers based on unrel...
ICE enforcement practices have generated multiple constitutional challenges, including First Amendment suits alleging retaliatory targeting of immigrant advocates and challenges tied to access-to-cour...
Courts and the federal government have awarded a mix of remedies to U.S. citizens wrongfully detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE): individual monetary settlements, injunctive and decl...
Federal courts have repeatedly constrained ICE’s detainer program, finding that detainers issued without judicial warrants or individualized probable-cause assessments raise Fourth Amendment and statu...