Index/People/Judge Lewis Kaplan

Judge Lewis Kaplan

Fact-Checks

15 results
Nov 18, 2025
Most Viewed

Was Donald Trump convicted of rape

A civil jury in New York found Donald Trump liable for sexually abusing columnist E. Jean Carroll and for defaming her, and ordered roughly $5 million in damages; jurors did not find him liable for ra...

Jan 12, 2026
Most Viewed

What exactly was on the 2005 'Access Hollywood' tape and how have courts and juries treated it as evidence in other cases?

The 2005 “Access Hollywood” tape is a hot-mic recording of Donald Trump and Billy Bush in which Trump boasts about kissing, groping and trying to have sex with women who were not his wife and uses the...

Dec 6, 2025
Most Viewed

What role did the Access Hollywood tape play in the E. Jean Carroll case?

The Access Hollywood tape was admitted as evidence in E. Jean Carroll’s suit because Judge Lewis Kaplan concluded jurors could reasonably infer from the 2005 recording that Trump had “in fact” contact...

Dec 17, 2025

What specific incidents did E. Jean Carroll allege and when did they occur?

E. Jean Carroll has alleged that Donald J. Trump sexually assaulted her in a dressing room at Bergdorf Goodman in Manhattan in the mid‑1990s (specifically described in reporting as 1995–1996 or 1996)....

Nov 20, 2025

What role did the Access Hollywood tape play in Trump's sexual assault accusations?

The 2005 "Access Hollywood" tape — in which Donald Trump said a celebrity “can do anything” to women and described grabbing women — became a focal point linking his lewd comments to later accusations ...

Feb 6, 2026

How did Judge Lewis Kaplan and the Second Circuit describe the Carroll verdict in later rulings and opinions?

treated the jury’s findings in the first as dispositive for later proceedings, repeatedly saying the jury had “plainly established” key facts and even certifying one of ’s appeals as “frivolous,” whil...

Feb 5, 2026

How did public figures and media react to e. jean carroll’s allegations?

Public figures and media reacted to ’s allegations with fierce polarization: many mainstream outlets and legal commentators treated the court findings and jury verdicts as a significant legal vindicat...

Feb 4, 2026

How did the E. Jean Carroll trial proceed and what evidence did the jury consider?

between and produced a May 2023 jury finding that Trump sexually abused and defamed Carroll and a January 2024 damages trial that resulted in a vastly larger award for defamation — outcomes later uphe...

Jan 18, 2026

What evidence and witness testimony did E. Jean Carroll present at her trial?

E. Jean Carroll’s trial presentation combined her own detailed in‑court testimony about an alleged 1990s sexual assault with corroborating witnesses, documentary exhibits and pattern evidence includin...

Jan 7, 2026

What specific evidence did jurors cite when finding Donald Trump liable for sexual abuse of E. Jean Carroll?

A federal jury found Donald Trump civilly liable for sexually abusing E. Jean Carroll based on a mix of Carroll’s own testimony, corroborating witness accounts she spoke to immediately after the alleg...

Jan 6, 2026

What physical or documentary evidence was introduced in the settlement with Prince Andrew?

The settlement between Prince Andrew and Virginia Giuffre did not introduce new physical exhibits or documentary evidence as part of a public trial record because the case was resolved out of court an...

Dec 11, 2025

What are the latest developments in the E. Jean Carroll sexual assault case against Donald Trump?

President Trump has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to review and overturn a $5 million civil verdict that a Manhattan jury found he sexually abused and defamed writer E. Jean Carroll; the petition argue...

Dec 8, 2025

What appeals or legal challenges to E. Jean Carroll's judgments remain pending after December 2025?

As of the latest reporting in these sources, two main post-judgment avenues remain in play after December 2025: President Trump has petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court to review the $5 million civil jud...

Nov 15, 2025

are rape allegations against trump true

A 2023 federal jury in New York found Donald Trump civilly liable for sexually abusing E. Jean Carroll and for defaming her, and awarded Carroll $5 million — but that same jury did not find him liable...

Nov 11, 2025

What legal arguments did Donald Trump use in the E. Jean Carroll case?

Donald Trump’s legal strategy in the E. Jean Carroll litigation centered on contesting the trial court’s evidentiary rulings, attacking Ms. Carroll’s credibility and motives, and arguing that the intr...