Index/People/Sonia Sotomayor

Sonia Sotomayor

US Supreme Court justice since 2009

Fact-Checks

23 results
Jan 28, 2026
Most Viewed

How has the Supreme Court ruled on presidential immunity for unofficial acts tied to Jan. 6 and election‑subversion charges?

in v. held in a 6–3 decision that presidents enjoy absolute immunity for a "core" of official acts and at least presumptive immunity for other official acts, while denying immunity for purely unoffici...

Dec 4, 2025
Most Viewed

What federal laws prohibit racial profiling by ICE agents?

Federal law and the Constitution contain limits on racial profiling by federal agents: the Fourth Amendment prohibits unreasonable stops and seizures and requires “specific articulable facts” to justi...

Jan 28, 2026
Most Viewed

What Supreme Court rulings since 2024 have changed how nationwide injunctions are issued?

The ’s most consequential change since 2024 is its June 27, 2025 decision in v. , which the Court held substantially curtails the ability of lower federal courts to issue “universal” or nationwide inj...

Jan 26, 2026

What legal arguments and precedents are cited for and against the claim that ending birthright citizenship is constitutional?

The debate over whether ending is constitutional turns on one phrase in — "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" — and on whether long-standing practice and precedent like United States v. control that...

Dec 4, 2025

How has the Supreme Court ruled on including 'aliens' in the decennial census historically?

The Supreme Court has repeatedly steered clear of definitively resolving whether “aliens” without lawful status must be included in the decennial census apportionment base, dismissing or declining to ...

Jan 28, 2026

What have court rulings said about the constitutionality of nitrogen hypoxia and other gas‑based execution methods?

Federal and state courts have so far declined to categorically enjoin , applying the ’s method‑of‑execution framework that requires inmates to identify a feasible, readily implemented alternative and ...

Dec 9, 2025

Did supreme court say president can have political opponents killed?

The Supreme Court’s 2024 ruling expanding presidential immunity has prompted repeated media and legal debate over whether a president could order the killing of a political opponent and be immune from...

Nov 11, 2025

What were the major Supreme Court cases involving the Obama administration?

The Obama administration litigated or was affected by several high-profile Supreme Court decisions that shaped health care, labor relations, campaign finance, and regulatory power; the most frequently...

Oct 7, 2025

Can a president declare martial law without congressional approval?

A president cannot unilaterally impose a nationwide, long-term martial law regime without engaging Congress and the courts; statutory authorities like the Insurrection Act and National Guard federaliz...

Jan 14, 2026

How have courts ruled so far on Trump’s claims of presidential immunity and on challenges to the special counsel appointment?

The Supreme Court in Trump v. United States held that presidents enjoy a mix of absolute immunity for “core” constitutional powers and at least presumptive immunity for other “official” acts, while le...

Dec 18, 2025

Which justices sided with the majority and dissent in the 7-2 immunity decision and why?

The reporting and opinions show this was not a 7–2 decision but a sharply divided 6–3 Supreme Court ruling that recognized substantial presidential immunity from criminal prosecution for some official...

Feb 4, 2026

How did conservative or liberal justices vote on high-profile Trump-era cases?

Across a string of high‑profile disputes ’s conservative bloc has often sided with presidential prerogatives—especially on emergency orders, executive removal power and limits on nationwide injunction...

Feb 3, 2026

what happened in noem v. perdomo?

, on September 8, 2025, granted the federal government’s emergency request to stay a district-court injunction that had limited “roving” stops in , effectively allowing agents to resume stops that rel...

Feb 3, 2026

has there been any notable court cases involving injunctive relief prior to perdomo v. noem?

v. Lyons stands as the principal pre‑Perdomo decision shaping courts’ approach to injunctive relief, especially the Article III standing required for forward‑looking relief, and more recent decisions ...

Feb 3, 2026

What legal arguments have Trump’s lawyers made about presidential immunity in criminal matters, and how have courts responded?

’s lawyers urged the courts to recognize for presidential conduct—arguing absolute protection for acts within the “outer perimeter” of official responsibilities and pressing that , not criminal courts...

Jan 31, 2026

What legal standards did the Supreme Court outline for distinguishing official from unofficial presidential acts?

in v. set a three-part framework: for acts within a president’s core constitutional powers, presumptive immunity for acts within the “outer perimeter” of official responsibility, and no immunity for “...

Jan 29, 2026

How have prior Supreme Court immunity decisions (e.g., Nixon v. Fitzgerald) been used to shape arguments in Trump v. United States?

The civil-immunity framework became the keystone precedent both sides invoked in v. : defenders argued Fitzgerald’s recognition of absolute immunity for official acts supported sweeping protection fro...

Jan 27, 2026

How did Barack Obama and Donald Trump differ in judicial appointments and Supreme Court nominations?

and diverged sharply in both scale and strategy when reshaping the : Obama made a larger number of total over eight years and emphasized diversity and professional credentials, while Trump — working w...

Jan 27, 2026

How have federal appellate courts treated organizer liability for violence at protests after the Fifth Circuit’s McKesson decision?

Federal appellate treatment of organizer liability split sharply after embraced a novel “” theory in Doe v. Mckesson, holding that a protest leader can be sued in negligence for violence by third part...

Jan 26, 2026

How have courts interpreted “obstruction of justice” in immigration aggravated-felony determinations after Pugin v. Garland?

in held that an offense may qualify as “relating to obstruction of justice” for the ’s aggravated-felony bar even if the crime does not require a pending investigation or proceeding, resolving a circu...